29 May 2005
extraordinarily extra ordinary
So I've watched Jersey girl and you know, it wasn't awful. It wasn't horrible.
It was, in a word, conventional. Smith may have thrown in a little bit of bawdy language (but using actual terms, not euphemisms) and a slightly smarter soundtrack (if not an entirely appropriate one, as somebody somewhere criticized one of the Springsteen tracks being used to backscore a sappy montage or some sort) but otherwise it's a fairly standard take on the inappropriate parent genre. George Carlin puts in a fairly serious performance, which is unique if not disappointing, and in fact is overshadowed by Stephen Root (from NewsRadio and Office space).
Overall it was missing something, and it wasn't just his and Jason Mewes's cameo as stoner duo Jay & Silent Bob. It's missing that Kevin Smith spark that sets is just off of the mainstream. In most cases the directors slog through mainstream films to ultimately make the interesting stuff. Smith has done it backward, toiling away on interesting little pieces so that he can apparently make middle-of-the-road claptrap like Jersey girl. Not to say that Jay and Silent Bob strike back was all that good, but it wasn't like anything else that came out that month.
But hey, everybody makes a few missteps. Peter Jackson, who can now do no wrong, once made Bad taste and had it to be considered his best work.
Once Smith dumps more of his usual crew (really, Kev, the Ben Affleck train isn't one you want to be staying on much longer) and smartens the scripts back up, he might be back on track.